Auto Insurance Review by Hayley G - Preferred Insurance Agency La Crosse, WI The agents and staff at Preferred Insurance do an incredible job in customer service, communication, and saving people money! I had one of their agents (Peter Olson) run me a free quote to compare with my current auto insurance and Peter got back to me within a few hours with a quote that was the same company and coverage but $480 cheaper per year. 5/5 recommend!