The Risks and Benefits Of Roof Replacement During Winter Homeowners often call roofing contractors because of problems with leaks. When the pros arrive at their home, they do a thorough inspection and find that they need a roof replacement. Most homeowners ask if they can wait until spring to have a new roof. Intuitively, replacing a roof in the winter does not seem to be a good idea. Let us determine this by consider three important components that have a significant effect of the final results. These are the human factor, the capacity of the tools to perform, as well as the shingle product.