Antonella's Pizzeria

I've had several of the items from the menu and they're all very good. Service is great people are friendly. Restaurant is very clean. Pizza is thin crust with a nice crispy under carriage.


Would recommend.

Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch! Great find! Great variety of lunch specials through 4pm. I opted for the 1/2 hero (Italian cold cut, but you can choose from several heroes) and small Caesar salad. This special is #4 on the lunch menu; it's called "Twice As Nice". The salad was a generous portion for a side salad and tasted good. The hero was HUGE! Probably an 8" sub, packed with Italian meats and cheese. I had to eat it open face, with a knife and fork as it was too big to close to bite into. The pizza looked good! I think I'll try that next time.

This place is small. Only 4 tables inside, and just a couple outside. If you want to dine in, visit during off hours or he prepared yo wait for a table - Butnthe wait will be well worth it!

Highly recommend!

I'm from NYC and my review may be a bit bias. I was disappointed to see their Margherita pizza look like a regular pizza with tomatoes on it (see my picture below). There was no basil, nor garlic, nor were there any mozz balls. Taste wise...when I bit into the tomato, it felt like I was literally biting into a tomato instead of the sauce or cheese taking over. Their crust is decent so no complaints there.

The wings are fried then tossed in sauce. I prefer baked wings and less sauce but overall decent meat.

I asked a question if the pasta was good and it was removed. I don't know if it was the owner or another user. I was told to leave a review instead.

I tried it yesterday. The sauce to spaghetti ratio was high in the favor of meat sauce. I would say it was ok. The salad that came with it wasn't good. It wasn't fresh and crisp.

I thought the prices were high, but it may just be the area. This location reminded me of a NY pizza by the slice type place. I guess that is why I thought the prices were high. It was the lack of atmosphere. I had their pizza a long time ago and it was good.

We were in the area and looking for an affordable bite to eat. My boyfriend was in the mood for pizza, and Antonella's Pizzeria came up when I searched pizza. So why not, we love trying new places, and the reviews seemed pretty good. They had good lunch specials, so we both rolled with the 2 slices & salad special. They had many other lunch special choices as well. I'm sure we will be back to try out a pasta ones most likely in the future. The salad was bigger than expected but fresh and good. I upgraded my slices for tomatoe & spinach, it was hood i just felt they overdid it on the toppings. Overall, we enjoyed the food. There were not many seating spots but we chose to sit on their patio since it was so hot inside. They stay busy tho I will say, they had a lot of pickup orders and uber eats it looked like. I say if you're in the area, give it a shot, and we will be back.

WOW! I ordered through Uber eats but before I ordered I always check out the reviews and man I now know why people highly recommended this place. The taste of it tastes fresh and so good. I was also surprised how it wasn't so greasy but just the right amount of grease. Definitely want to check it out in person next time.

The pizza is very good 10/10
the garlic knots are pretty good very garlicky
The service was good VERY small place if you decide to eat there

This mom and pop restaurant is secluded in one of the many nice spots in Winter Park. Stopped in, was greeted by the waitress and looked over the menu. They have a great selection of pizza, calzones, wings and so much more. I ended up doing a create your own pizza (steak, extra cheese, sun dried tomatoes and spinach) and 10 wings extra crispy with a Snapple Apple. They don't have a liquor selection but have select wines and beers. Seating is limited.

Let me just say the pizza and wings were made to perfection! I enjoyed it sooo much. Definitely reminds me of authentic Italian. This won't be my last time here.

Great pizza! Got a 10 inch pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. Pizza crust was crispy, and the knots had extra garlic which I love. The location it self is small and cozy. There are about 4 tables inside and 2 outside. Food was quick to come out, even though they seemed to do a big take out business. They have out front pick up service and they take it out to your care. Menu offers pizzas, calzones, pastas, and the desserts look great. Fantastic service, staff was so great. Highly recommend you check this place out or order for takeout

Yesterday I stopped by Antonella's Pizza for the first time with my friend! It was such a cute little place that had delicious food and large portions. We started off with their Pasta e Fagioli Soup! All of their soups are homemade and this was exactly what we needed on a rainy day. You HAVE to dip your garlic bread into the soup!

Next we tried their Mambo Combo on their lunch menu which come with chicken parmigiana, manicotti, and meatballs. It was perfect since we wanted a taste of a bit of everything. For one of our entrees, we ordered the Penne alla Vodka, and this definitely has some spice. The flavor was amazing and I loved how the pasta was al dente. The spice builds so be prepared! I love spice, so this was perfect for me.

Lastly, we had to try one of their pizzas! We got the 14" Margherita Pizza which was massive, garlicky, and cheesy. This Margherita was very different from the ones I'm used to, they put fresh tomatoes on the pie and it was great! I do wish there was a bit more sauce, but other than that, it was incredible. The crust has such an amazing texture and taste. I definitely recommend checking out this place to try some amazing pizza, pasta and other Italian dishes! I can't wait to try some more of their menu next time! It is a family owned business so the staff were so so friendly. Thank you to Emily for being so helpful and kind!

- Homemade Pasta e Fagioli Soup
- Garlic Bread
- Mambo Combo
- Penne alla Vodka
- Margarita Pizza
- Cannoli