San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

The best Neapolitan pizza! We've been here a few times visiting Milwaukee and it never disappoints, so good! We had a group of 10 this time and the service was quick and the food was amazing we had the bruschetta, several different pizzas and our friend had the gluten free crust and loved it too. Will be back again!

This place is amazing!! Call first to get reservations.I tried walking in 3 times and they were packed each time. it's a small place but the bar seats were perfect..it's actually a front row seat to watch the pizza magic.. The doppia calabrese is heaven on earth. If you enjoy good pizza this place is the place to be! The service was excellent , quick and knowledgeable about the menu items.


You have to try this for yourself!

The Della Casa salad was--how to say--a container of mostly air.

The pizzas were really good.

The food took almost twice as long as promised, so that was frustrating.

Pizza is so good! Drinks are a bit expensive. Highly recommend the Maria Carmella pizza and Tiramisu!

Have been wanting to try San Giorgio for a while now, and I am so happy we finally had the chance to go. I had heard great things from people who had eaten here before and it definitely lived up to the hype. The pizza was delicious and there were so many options that looked wonderful. We did not have a reservation but got a spot at the bar pretty quick. I would recommend calling ahead though to get a reservation as the place was very busy.

Food: 10/10. Started with a Caesar salad that had perfectly crisp lettuce and freshly shaved Parmesan cheese. I knew as soon as I got it, this meal would be insane. Followed it up with a San Giorgio pizza. One of the best pizzas I've ever had. The pancetta was done perfectly. The sunny side egg was innovative and a great complimentary flavor.

Service: 10/10, received our food quickly and didn't have to wait for drinks.

Ambiance: 10/10 Pretty cool spot with an ability to sit around the brick oven. The interior design was contemporary and tasteful. Vibes were overall excellent.

Overall: I can't wait to back here. I'd get a pizza here every week for the rest of my life

10/10 food, service and dining vibes. A restaurant that will not go wrong in downtown Milwaukee. I have enjoyed the dining experience here.

Tonight we were on our way to downtown so we made a last-min phone call at 4:30PM hoping to reserve a table. The lady was very helpful and arranged a table for us for 5PM. So I highly suggest you make a reservation if you are going during weekends.

We arrived at 4:53PM. After checking with the super friendly host, we were immediately seated near the open pizza cooking area. Loved the casual delightful vibes!

The food was amazing. We got the Americana pizza, the meatballs, the Paccheri a la Genovese and the warm coffee cocktail. Highly recommend all of the food. Especially the flavorful Paccheri a la Genovese if you want some pasta! The Americana is a star shape pizza with rich ricotta cheese filling in the dough and has some super crispy pepperoni and juicy sausage meat on top. The meatballs dish include two big meatballs immersed in the red sauce - good for two or three people to share!

Best pizza in Milwaukee. Really authentic stuff and the atmosphere is pretty nice too.

Recommended by one of my favorite professors, San Giorgio was the best meal I've had in Milwaukee.

Orders:

Burrata: the perfect appetizer. Delicious bread with cheese, arugula, little tomatoes, and olive oil. Would order again.

Paccheri Genovese: from their special menu - perfectly cooked pasta in a hardy beef chuck and onion sauce. The star of the table. It was literally SO good - a lovely balance of flavors.

Ilario Pizza: sausage, mushrooms, and cheese. The crust was so light and fluffy. I liked the pasta better, but the pizza was still fantastic on its own.

Margherita Pizza: a classic done really well. Fresh and light. A+

San Pelligrino: both the limonata (lemon) and aranciata (orange) were great! If you don't like stuff that's too tart, I'd go with the orange flavor - it was a bit sweeter.

Our server was super attentive and made sure to let us know about everything that they had available. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, and the service was wonderful. We got to sit at the bar where they made the pizzas, and it was fun to interact with everyone at/behind the counter. I can see this making a cute date spot. Be sure to make a reservation because they can get quite busy!

If we hadn't ordered a salad, this might have been a 5 star review. But the salad was so, so bad (we had the one with apples and nuts and blue cheese) that it almost ruined it for us. But the pizza was tasty and the roasted chicken and potatoes was also quite good.