Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Electronics, Telecommunications, Mobile Phones
in Mobile Phone Accessories, Telecommunications, Internet Service Providers
Amenities and More
About the Business
Buying & Selling New & Used Toys Collectibles Comics Trading Cards Video Games Vinyl Records Arcade
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Toying Around.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
6 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- A C.Gig Harbor, WA2146Jul 28, 2023
Amazing store, staff is so friendly. I only had a short time there but can't wait to go back. 1980s wrestling figures, always wanted those when I was young, and the have a nice variety. So glad to find this in Johnstown, can't wait to start traveling for their summer block party. Definitely support this local business, is a blessing to Johnstown to have it.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Beth F.Middleburgh, NY2780145Feb 2, 2020
My husband wanted to look at comics to purchase and as a geek, this store was great to visit! Although my husband wasn't used to comic bins not being organized or in alphabetical order, which made him take hours to sort through them, I enjoyed looking at the rooms and all of the collectible memorabilia!
For my patience and trouble, I was pleasantly surprised that the person minding the store graciously told me to take the pins I picked out for waiting so long! Ha!
There's so much to see here if you're into anything geeky or nerdy, it's truly impossible to make a list ... so I took a bunch of pictures instead! Enjoy!
Once again, Johnstown delivers with having a Main Street you truly can love -- one-of-a-kind shopping and cafes/restaurants!Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Pam M.Johnstown, NY01Mar 5, 2019
Great store, staff and selection. They always go above and beyond for example my little man (5) goes every week as his reward for doing great at school, sports and home, this past Friday he got two figures, unfortunately yesterday his new puppy ate them, he was devastated, I mentioned it on a post on their page, boom a personal message and they arranged to get both these hard to find items in the store for him. Awesome store and people
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Mr. C.Castleton-on-Hudson, NY239Feb 10, 2018
All I can say is I am upset I've never been there earlier than today. Wall to wall toys and collectibles for fans of any and every different brand/genre you can think of. I went there hoping to find one thing I needed for my collection and within 5 mins found so much that I will have to go back. Super friendly staff as well. Highly recommended. New customer for life.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Carol B.Watervliet, NY9745Jun 26, 2016First to Review
Great place. Shelves and shelves of goodies and fun, easy to wile away hours digging through every kind of comic/cartoon obsession. Unique T-shirts, and a willingness to help find anything not readily accessible, keeps me coming back.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Raymond R.Rome, NY30444Sep 16, 2016
My wife and I travel throughout the Northeast and visit many Comic Book Shops. This is a great one. We make an effort to always stop here when driving to Albany and points east of us.
They have a great selection of back issues at great prices. Staff is always attentive and friendly.
Although we are really only into comics, we still marvel at the great selection of toys they sell.
You will not be disappointed.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0