Menu
Popular dishes
What's the vibe?
See all 120
Inside
120 photos
See all 39
Outside
39 photos
See all 838
All photos
838 photos
People also searched for
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Seafood, Cajun/creole
in Chicken Shop, Chicken Wings, Fast Food
Amenities and More
About the Business
We're bringing the NYC experience to Honolulu through pizza, pasta, salad, coffee and beer!
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Yellow Cab Pizza Company.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
308 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Chris K.Honolulu, HI025Nov 12, 2023
Great service, delicious salads and the pizzas would have been excellent if they would have been cooked a little longer. Crust was still soft and a little doughy but still delicious after popping in the toaster oven.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Alexis H.Honolulu, HI111160563Mar 2, 2024
We ordered the garden specialty pizza. The guy didn't even cut the bell pepper, he put one long strip on each pizza slice. Lol never had that before. It made it difficult to eat. The pizza wasn't special, with no special flavors or taste. Just an ordinary pizza. We also ordered the garlic parmesan wings. These were good. A little bit oily, but the taste was good.
The cashier was a young Filipino boy. He was nice. Service was as expected, and good.
There are two large spaces to have parties. The dining area is also spacious. I can see why it's always empty though. Hard to beat Costco pizza... it's bigger in size and more affordable. I was hoping this place would stand out, but it didn't.Helpful 2Thanks 1Love this 2Oh no 0 - Jan 4, 2024
Happy National Spaghetti Day!!
They just messed up on a classic on this special day and that's really sad and explains why there no one in here. Sharing the same lot with Costco I've always wanted to give them a try now who doesn't like pizza and pasta not this one and on this day though it would be classic place to go...wrong!
I ordered the "Aglio Olio Chicken Pasta" and I'll tel you if you want veggies get their salad cause you won't find it in nothing much more so this dish. Classically this dish is made of four ingredients (pasta, garlic, olive oil and red pepper flakes) hoping they used olive oil...shrug! There's zero chili flakes and just about zero garlic which leaves a bland pasta with oil and sundried tomatoes and that was it nothing else besides some bland chicken.
The service is minimal you pay at the counter and pick it up yourself the inside is quite large and roomy with nice decor and a lot of seating but sadly that's the only bright side besides the free parking right outside.Helpful 21Thanks 2Love this 8Oh no 6 - Chris B.Waipahu, HI011Apr 24, 2024
I ordered a meat lovers pizza. It was NOT very good. One of the worst pizza's I ever had. Not much meat, the crust/sauce was NOT tasty. Cheese was decent. Plenty of seating but where I sat the table was sticky & needed a wipe down. Customer service was excellent.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 167125129Jul 9, 2023
Costco food court was closing up so we decided to try this place out since it was in the same parking lot.
We were surprised by how big the place is, an open seating area + 2 private room dens, cute and simple decor, and an ordering counter right in the center.
We opted for a large pizza with half and half toppings. The pizza itself took about 15 minutes to come out, served with paper plates. A really big pie with ALOT of cheese-- so much that we could barely see the toppings underneath the cheesy layer.
I'm a crust kind of girl-- so my happiness with any pie is 90% dependent on the crust. The crust was just alright. Not too thin, but thick enough to have a cardboard feel. Flavor of the cheese and meat toppings were standard-- nothing to remember it by. Their tomato sauce was generous and I dug the tanginess and flavor.
Overall, I can't say I'd come back to this place but it may be worth going if you're feeding a whole gang of kids or a big party. Their prices are fair for how much you get!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jean-luc P.Kapolei, HI104628Aug 22, 2023
This is why you should never have just a bunch of young kids running your business. Typically, they have no customer service skills, and just don't care.
Case in point, I ordered "Honey Garlic Wings" and got "Parmesan Garlic Wings".
Honey garlic wings does not have parmesan on it!
After getting the wings, I let the cashier know that they gave me parmesan wings by mistake. He said no, those were honey garlic wings.
I showed it to him and said they have parmesan all over it.
However, he insisted that it was the correct honey garlic wings.
The guy couldn't admit their mistake and just make me a new batch of wings.
Smelled like parmesan, tasted like parmesan, WELL I GUESS IT MUST HAVE BEEN PARMESAN THEN!!!!!
Next time i want wings, I'll just go to Wingstop down the street.
Lesson learned!Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 0 - Aug 9, 2023
The place was clean, big and empty. Perfect for a lunch party of one. I got just a plain cheese pizza and was really underwhelmed. The crust was thinner than I thought (not all bad) and there were bites with extra seasoning on it. It was weird. Staff seemed bored I guess since they didn't have a lunch rush (walked in at 12:15pm. I would try this place again just because I really want to like it
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Feb 28, 2023
Used to work behind it and we used to pass to go to Costco or Max's or L&L. Finally decided it was time to try and get for our office. Ordered online...suuuuper easy to order and pay even during closed hours. Got 4 18" pizzas...all were hot and ready when I had requested them. Ask for peppers and cheese if you want them.
Ordered Chicken Pesto, NY's Finest (like a supreme), Manhattan Meatlovers, and Pepperoni. I tried small slivers of all except for the Pepperoni. Tasty. The chicken was a little dry, but otherwise good. I think I liked the Meatlovers the best. Kinda NY pizza-ish...at least what I know of it as a Hawaii girl who visited NY many times. What I like is that there was choke toppings...almost all the way to the end. A little limper than I like, but maybe cuz wasn't fresh. I think, take it home and throw it in the oven lil while crisp up the crust...winnahs.
Good prices. Worker was super nice. I'll definitely go back...
1 issue...homeless guy peep'n in at the door, touching it and I just don't like anyone's germs. But I know the area and really he didn't do anything bad.Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 2 - May 5, 2023
I was sick and not feeling up to cooking. I hadn't eaten all day and realized I was feeling hungry, that's a good sign right?! Via texts my family decided it was going to be a pizza night. I definitely have my usual places but we decided to try someplace new to us, that we could get delivered via uber eats. Yellow cab pizza had a good online menu so I knew what to expect. We got the New Yorker, the largest size. I also ordered the honey garlic wings, bone in. After placing my order I got a call from YCP stating that they were out of the bone in wings, so I gave the ok for the boneless. I really appreciated the service via the phone call. Turns out boneless is like boneless thighs. Since we didn't dine in, there wasn't any ambiance to rate...no booths, tables, decor, volume level, but I'm guessing they are all good.
Helpful 1Thanks 2Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Italian, Karaoke, Sports Bars
in Seafood